Right before Easter break, Joel Brand, one of our youth ministry majors, brought to my attention that hardly anyone names their son Judas, but that there are a whole lot or Peters. I smiled when he said it because one of the things I love about my job is being around so many people who are thinking profound thoughts and who challenge me to consider thinking new thoughts as well. And this small statement challenged me to consider why there are so few sons named Judas.
In Matthew 26:14 it says, "Then one of the Twelve—the one called Judas Iscariot—went to the chief priests and asked, 'What are you willing to give me if I hand Jesus over to you?' So they counted out for him thirty silver coins. From then on Judas watched for an opportunity to hand him over." Later that same evening Judas walked up to Jesus, and gave him a kiss of friendship as he betrayed him into the hands of those who wanted him dead.
Some would tell you this is the great tragedy of Judas, the fact that he sold Jesus out for 30 pieces of silver. But that alone can’t be why we don’t name our child Judas because Peter denied Jesus, not just once, but three times, and we still name our sons Peter.
When Judas, who had betrayed him, saw that Jesus was condemned, he was seized with remorse and returned the thirty silver coins to the chief priest and the elders. “I have sinned,” he said, “for I have betrayed innocent blood.” “What is that to us?” they replied. “That’s your responsibility.” So Judas threw the money into the temple and left. Then went away and hanged himself. Matthew 27:3-5
The reason we don’t often name our children Judas is not because of the betrayal, everyone denies or betrays Jesus sometime and even the most chosen among us, even the closest to Jesus often deny him three times in a single sitting. We all have our “30 pieces of silver” that we will deny Jesus for. For Peter perhaps it was not getting caught or avoiding a difficult road or keeping his reputation intact. We do all have our price and yet we still name our children Peter and so betrayal and denial cannot be the reason we rarely name our children Judas.
And if you read the text, Judas is as repentant as Peter, maybe even more. Peter weeps bitterly when he realizes what he’s done, but he keeps his denial private and he confesses to God alone. Judas on the other hand makes a public display of his repentance. Filled with remorse, Judas even goes back to the temple to make his confession and tries to make things right by telling the truth and giving back what he gained in the exchange for his lie.
So why do we still name our sons Peter but very rarely Judas? I believe it is because of the tragic end of Judas’ life. There is no written redemption in it. The story ends badly, and I wonder, did it have to? Did it have to end so tragic?
Jesus does say that Judas was “doomed to destruction so that Scripture could be fulfilled.” But was Judas doomed because of Judas? Did Jesus say Judas was doomed because there was something inherently evil about the guy? I mean, there is some evidence that he was perhaps a bit greedy, but if that counts us tragic, there aren’t too many of us that aren’t doomed. Was Judas doomed because of Judas, or were there more factors that contributed to his fate? Is it possible that Judas’s story is tragic not just because Judas messed up but because the community around him dropped the ball as well?
Think about it. Judas, filled with remorse, goes running back to the religious people to tell them he made a mistake and you know what their response was? “What is that to us?” they replied. “That’s your responsibility.” And I can’t help but think about how different the end of Judas’ life might have been if only he had run into someone who really knew Jesus.
What if Judas in the midst of his remorse had run into Zaccheus or the Samaritan woman or the woman who had been caught in adultery? And what if they took time to notice him and said, “What’s wrong, Judas?” And what if through the sobs Judas had said, “I messed up and I can’t fix it.” And what if, right then and there, one of them had witnessed to Judas what they themselves had experienced with Jesus. “It’s okay, Judas, don’t run away and don’t do anything crazy, just go back to Jesus. He is so good. He’ll fix it.” What if Judas would have run into a witness who was willing to testify to the goodness of Jesus?
I think one faithful witness could have turned this story from a tragedy into a story of God’s mercy and grace and perhaps then we would have named our kids Judas just as frequently as we name them Peter. But all Judas ran into were religious people that said, “What is that to us?”
Before Jesus ascended into heaven he communicated that his desire was that his followers would become witnesses, “in Jerusalem and in Judea and Samaria and to the ends of the earth.” When we quote that we often put the emphasis on to the ends of the earth. But I wonder if when Jesus said it he thought of Judas, the one that was lost in Jerusalem. And I wonder if when he commissioned his followers, he said, “You will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in Judea and Samaria and to the ends of the earth,” with the hopes that even in the Holy City, in the hearts of the most religious people there would also be a witness to his mercy and grace.